Cracked Tree Trunk: When a Split Is a Hazard and What to Do

A cracked tree trunk: minor flaw or warning sign?

A cracked tree trunk is easy to miss until you are standing right next to it: a long split in the bark, sometimes deep enough to show bare wood. Some cracks are old frost cracks a tree has lived with for years. Others are a warning that a large stem could break off in the next storm. A tree near a house, garage, driveway or play area can do real damage if it fails, so a crack is worth a closer look.

This guide explains why tree trunks crack in our climate, how to tell a minor crack from a serious one, what the finding means in an inspection report and what to do next.

Why tree trunks crack in Fargo-Moorhead

Red River Valley winters are hard on bark. On a sunny winter day the south and southwest side of a trunk can warm far above the air temperature; NDSU Extension notes that the southwest side can be as much as 77°F warmer than the north side. When the sun goes down, the outer bark and wood cool quickly while the inside stays warmer, and that uneven shrinking can split the trunk.

Frost cracks

Frost cracks are vertical splits, often on the southwest side, that can run several feet up the trunk. Manitoba Agriculture notes that they often start at an older weak spot in the wood, may close in summer and reopen in winter, and can build ridges of callus wood called frost ribs. On their own they are rarely fatal, but every opening is a way in for decay fungi, and Illinois Extension notes that repeated cracking can weaken a tree.

Sunscald

Sunscald is related winter damage: an elongated, sunken or cracked patch of dead bark, usually on the south or southwest side. University of Minnesota Extension lists young, newly planted and thin-barked trees, including maple, linden, honeylocust, mountain ash, crabapple, cherry and plum, as the most likely to be hurt.

Codominant stems and included bark

Many of the cracks that worry arborists most start where a tree divides into two or more stems of about the same size, called codominant stems. When the stems grow tight together, bark gets trapped in the joint (included bark) instead of forming a strong union. Illinois Extension explains that included bark can act as a wedge that splits the stems apart, and that maple, ash and elm commonly form these unions. A crack running down from a tight, V-shaped fork is a classic sign that the union is separating.

Storms, lightning and old wounds

Wind, ice, lightning and old injuries from mowers, trimmers or construction can also crack a trunk. Purdue Extension notes that cracks or seams that go through the bark and into the wood can lead to extensive decay.

Signs a cracked tree trunk may be dangerous

Not every crack means a tree has to come down. These signs point to a higher risk:

  • The crack goes into the wood or through the trunk. Illinois Extension says immediate action is warranted when splits extend through the bark into the wood, or when two or more cracks occur in the same area.
  • The crack runs down from a fork between two large stems, especially a tight, V-shaped one.
  • There is decay with it: soft or crumbly wood, cavities, or mushrooms and conks on the trunk or roots.
  • The crack opens and closes, or the stems move separately in the wind.
  • The tree has a new or worsening lean, or the soil is heaving or cracking at the base.
  • Branches above the crack are dead or dying.

Risk also depends on what is underneath. Purdue Extension points out that a tree is a risk only when it has a defect and a target it could hit, such as the house, a garage, a driveway, a neighbor’s roof or a play area. Purdue’s guide uses a target zone at least as wide as the tree is tall.

What this finding means in an inspection report

When we find a cracked tree trunk during an inspection, we note it and recommend further evaluation, especially when the tree is close enough to reach the home or other structures. A home inspection looks at the visible condition of trees near the house. It isn’t a tree risk assessment: we don’t climb trees, test the wood for decay or judge how strong a fork is. Those calls belong to an arborist.

Large trees near a house matter in other ways too. Roots can work their way into older sewer lines, as our article on sewer line failure and replacement explains, and overhanging limbs drop the leaves and seeds that fill clogged gutters. After a big storm, our guide to what summer storms can reveal about your home covers what else to check.

What to do about a cracked tree trunk

  1. Keep people and cars out of harm’s way. If a large cracked stem hangs over the house, a driveway or a play area, avoid parking or playing under it until it has been checked, especially in high wind.
  2. Call an ISA Certified Arborist. Purdue Extension recommends an arborist who understands tree risk assessment, and for a full assessment one with the ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualification (TRAQ). The arborist can judge how deep the crack goes, look for decay and recommend a plan.
  3. Expect one of a few outcomes. Purdue Extension notes that pruning can often reduce the risk, that cabling and bracing may be an option, and that removal should be an informed decision. Many frost cracks only need to be watched.
  4. Don’t paint, tar or fill the crack. University of Minnesota Extension, Illinois Extension and Manitoba Agriculture all advise against paint, tar or wound dressings on tree wounds.
  5. Leave climbing and big cuts to professionals. Never prune near power lines; contact your utility if a cracked tree is close to overhead lines.

How to prevent trunk cracks

  • Wrap young and thin-barked trees for winter. Use a white commercial tree wrap or white plastic guards in fall, and take them off in spring after the last frost. NDSU Extension recommends wrapping new trees for at least their first two winters, and sensitive species for about five. Avoid black tree guards.
  • Water trees well in fall. Illinois Extension recommends making sure trees are well hydrated going into winter.
  • Protect the bark. Keep mowers and string trimmers away from the trunk; a ring of mulch helps.
  • Prune young trees for structure. Ask an arborist about pruning young trees so one main stem leads and weak, tight forks don’t develop.
  • Check your trees regularly. Purdue suggests a check at least every three to five years, and it is worth a walk around after every major storm.

Cracked tree trunk: common questions

Can a cracked tree trunk heal?

Trees don’t heal the way people do; they seal wounds by growing new wood over them. Illinois Extension notes that a tree with small, infrequent cracks can survive and seal the split, but the crack stays inside the wood and can reopen in later winters.

Is a frost crack dangerous?

Usually not on its own; Manitoba Agriculture calls frost cracking rarely fatal. Decay can enter through the crack, though, and repeated cracking can weaken the tree. Have a long or deep crack checked, especially on a tree near the house.

Should I seal or fill a crack in a tree?

No. Extension services advise against paint, tar and wound dressings. Leave the crack open and have an arborist look at it.

Can a split tree be saved?

Sometimes. Pruning, or cabling and bracing a weak fork, can reduce the risk in some trees. Whether that is enough depends on how far the split goes, whether there is decay and what the tree could hit, which is a call for an arborist.

Who should check a tree for safety?

An ISA Certified Arborist, ideally one with the Tree Risk Assessment Qualification. The International Society of Arboriculture’s consumer site, TreesAreGood.org, has a Find an Arborist search.

Want a full look at your home and what is around it? Schedule a homeowner inspection, or learn more about our home buyer’s inspection.

Sources